Tuesday, 8 January 2013

Blog #1

Blog #1:

1. Write a paragraph explaining which of the approaches McMahan mentions is the most appealing to you.

          After reading the text book "Liturature and the Writing Process" by Elizabeth McMahan, Critical Approaches for Interpreting Literature, I have deceided that the readers response approach is the most appealing approach to myself. After reading this text, my understanding of what a readers response approach to critizing liturature is that, everyone reads and interprets everything in life very differently. This includes the way the read, interprete and understand a work of writing. It all depends on how they think and the things of events that they have experienced in their lifetime. Also, you could read a work of liturature at the age of twenty, have a certain understanding and interpretation of a work of writing and its underlying meaning. Then, read the same work of literature another twenty years from then, and have a completely different understanding. The way you think can change with maturity, and obviously, at that point in your life, you have had many more life events and life experienced to alter or effect your understanding and interpretation of a certain piece. I find this approach appealing because I find it very interesting that two different people can read the exact same work of literature, and still find themselves having completely different thoughts, interpretations and understandings. Without either of the two people being considered to have a wrong interpretation. Also, looking at the way I read pieces of literature, I feel that this is the approach I have been doing informally.

2. Put your favourite approach into practice analyzing any poem of your choice from our text.

          In the text, the poem "Not Waving but Drowning" by Stevie Smith, he telling a story simply about a man drowning. They begin by talking about how exciting and outgoing he used to be. "Poor chap, he always loved larking" and "and not waving but drowning" as said in the poem, highlights that point. He changes, from alive to dead, to lively to laying moaning. The poem begins calling the man who drowned a him, or man and then as the poem continues on he speaks of the person who drowned as I. The last two lines of the poem say "I was much too far out all my life, and not waving but drowning". This is probably talking about him in regards to his own life and how he treated life. He probably stayed distant from other people and didnt mind to be alone, wasnt loud and noticed.

No comments:

Post a Comment