Wednesday, 6 March 2013

Blog #9

"Stones" by Timothy Findley.

Thesis: Findley's short story "Stones" brings you through the experiences of a man who lost everything he once loved because of the effects war has had on him.

1. The effects it had on the man (Max) who actually experienced the war.
          1. He went from being a loving and caring father, to someone who changed into a completely opposite person. He now had nothing that he once loved. The major thing he lost, being his family.
          2. Highlight the things he did to his family before the war, and the things he did after that made him a different person. For example, before war, the man was very loving of his family. Everyone felt confortable being around him and they liked to be around him. While after war, people did everything to avoid making him angry, the man is swearing in front of his kids, made everyone uncomfortable and even broke his sons bone.

2. The effects the man's change had on his family and loved ones.
          1. The father, as stated in the first paragraph, when returned from war, made his family very uncomfortable to be around him. It was almost as if they were afraid of him.
          2. Some examples to cover could be how he broke his sons bone, he attacked his wife, he was easily aggitated, and isolated his children.

3. The true meaning behind the man's changed personality.
          1. The man was experiencing post-traumatic stress disorder. (Give the definition of this disorder and explain the symptoms)
          2. Throughout the story you learn that the man fled a battle, and his decision to fled a batter caused many others to die and be harmed. This could have caused some guilt. If someone experiences enough guilt, it can change them as a person.

Hills Like White Elephants by Earnest Hemmingway

Thesis: Hills like White Elephants by Earnest Hemingway is an excellent example of responsibility conflict between two adults.

1. Underlying decisions
          1. The two main characters must make a major decision. The have found themselves in a situation where she has to decide to get an abortion or not.
          2. One of the main characters, Jig, seems to be reassuring herself on how she is making the decision for the other main character, the American, and not for herself. She often says throughout the story "I dont care about me".

2. The American seems to make the decision, however, it is Jig that holds the responsibility.
          1. Jig is the women, she will be the one who naturally holds the responsibility of the child. Also, she feels responsible for herself, and the child that has yet to be born.
          2. The American, in everything he says to Jig, seems to be trying to tell her that she should in fact get the abortion. He says things along the lines of "It's really an awfully simple operation".

3. Decision made and responsibility taken.
          1. Jig feels responsible for all the characters in this story, herself, the baby, and the American. And her going through with the abortion or not is based on what her relationships with these people are, and weither or not she is willing to loose them.
          2. The american tells her they will only be happy if things go back to normal, and in order for that to happen, she must have the operation. Jig wants the american to love her, and if that means getting the operation, that is what she'll do.
          3. Jig takes all responsibility, she feels she needs to make the mistake that her and the american have done right. And an abortion is the only option to do do.

No comments:

Post a Comment